Monday, 18 November 2019

The Northern Ireland Protocol. What Does It Mean?

By Willie Drennan

The Withdrawal Agreement is a very complex and painful read. The majority of the British people have obviously not been able to study this long-winded monstrosity of legal jargon. They rely instead on the interpretations of media correspondents and their politicians of choice - most of whom seemingly haven't studied it in full either.

I have only read parts of the WA and have further developed a wee bald patch on the top of my head to prove  it.  But I have studied the NI Protocol section. The conclusion I have come to, to date, is that it is a horrendous treaty: not just for the Northern Irish part of the UK but for the whole of the UK.

The Backstop is still in there, camouflaged behind the complex legal jargon.

But I am no lawyer. So I have listed, and numbered, 20 of my understandings below in the hope that some legal experts, or highly evolved politicians, will be able to explain to me why I am wrong in my conclusions. I genuinely hope someone can.

1/ The European Court of Justice (ECJ) will rule supreme over any discrepancies that will arise out of the Northern Ireland (NI) Protocol.

2/During the Transition period, and for six years thereafter, the EU will be able to make changes to rules and regulations in Northern Ireland that will be binding in perpetuity, even in the event of the Protocol being rejected by the NI electorate.

3/The ECJ will rule supreme over such matters as trade, employment rights, human rights, equality rights, fishing, farming, environment and state aid.

4/The ECJ will rule supreme over any anomaly arising out of interpretation of the Belfast/Good Friday Agreement (GFA)

5/ Four years after end of Transition the MLA's in Stormont will have opportunity to vote on rejecting or continuing to accept the Protocol. This will be by majority vote which contravenes the Consent principle of the GFA, as commonly understood in NI/ ROI.

6/ Should NI vote to reject the terms of the Protocol the EU will have a further 2 years to establish alternative arrangements, which include examination and interpretation of the details of the GFA.

7/ It seems clear that in such circumstances the terms and conditions of the Protocol would cease to be law but it would be mandatory that they be replaced by alternative arrangements.

8/ The alternative arrangements would necessitate NI remaining in the EU's Single Market and Customs Union.

9/ NI could never simply leave all connections with the EU and the laws of the ECJ to return to being a full member of an independent UK.

10/ Even in the case that the UK has arranged a Free Trade Deal with the EU, with no political affiliations or implications, there would be no mechanism for NI to fully exit the EU.

11/ The regulatory Irish Sea Border means that NI would become economically independent of the UK and dependent on EU rules and regulations.

12/ The Sea Border would require new documentation and monitoring of goods travelling in both directions.

13/ Tariffs on goods being transported from GB to NI will apply when the EU believes there is potential for those goods to be moved on to the EU as that could interfere with their 'level playing field' guidelines.  This could apply to most goods entering NI until proof of final destination is ascertained. 

14/ Tariffs on goods from GB to NI could be reimbursed when proof is provided that the goods remained within NI, but this would not necessarily always be the case.

15/ NI businesses will be tied into the EU 's VAT system.

16/ NI will be liable to pay taxes and tariffs to the EU without having any political representation with that authority.

17/ The ECJ will rule supreme over any proposed changes to the Common Travel Area (CTA) where it impacts EU citizens and their families who are resident in Ireland.

18/ The fact that the ECJ will have legal authority over NI indefinitely means that it will also have some authority and influence over UK internal laws indefinitely or until such times as NI ceases to be officially part of the UK.

19/ It appears that the Protocol process effectively severs NI from the UK in contravention of both the GFA and the Act of Union of 1801 - without the people of NI being granted democratic opportunity to approve or disapprove.

20/ At very least, the Protocol disturbs the spirit of the GFA which could create huge political problems on the island of Ireland and reignite historic social division.


  1. This is a great assessment of this wee debacle we now find ourselves in today. 🇬🇧

  2. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.